At
least in Oklahoma.
It
has become something of an annual ritual. The Bible uses a phrase something
like, “In the spring of the year, the time when kings go forth to battle,” (1 Chronicles 20:1). It is as reliable as
the opening of tree buds. Every winter, state senator Josh Brecheen of Oklahoma
(I am in his district) introduces a creationist bill. It is not worded as a
creationist bill, but that is its intent. It is called the Religious Viewpoints
Antidiscrimination Act (SB 1765). Its stated purpose is to prevent science
teachers from penalizing students for their religious views. Therefore, an
evolutionist teacher cannot penalize a creationist student. In literal fact,
this would mean that a creationist teacher could not penalize a non-creationist
student either. Brecheen claims that evolution is a religion, the establishment
of which is unconstitutional.
This
bill is a solution to a problem that does not exist. The bill specifically
states that the student needs to know the scientific concepts. But I have never
heard of a case of a creationist student in Oklahoma getting penalized for
creationist viewpoints.
So
I celebrated Darwin’s birthday by sending emails to the members of the Senate
Education Committee. Those of you in Oklahoma might consider doing this also.
Here is what I sent to the chair of the committee. I used my AOL email rather
than my university email.
Dear Senator
Ford,
I wish to express
my opposition to Senator Brecheen's bill, SB 1765. I have written to this
committee almost every year in the past about this bill each time it recurs. I
am a professor and science writer, but am writing this letter as a citizen and
using my private email. I am president of the Oklahoma Academy of Sciences, but
my views are my own.
The bill is
unnecessary, as its main points are effectively covered by existing Oklahoma
curriculum standards. Nothing in the bill explains why we need a new state
law specifying what teachers already (are required to) do and have been
doing for decades. Teachers already teach strengths and weaknesses as part of
inquiry-based learning. The state of Oklahoma faces numerous challenges and I
do not believe the Senate needs to take its time to debate and enact
unnecessary legislation.
I realize that
Senator Brecheen considers evolution to be a religion, but it is not. It is a
scientific theory based on a great amount of evidence, which I have outlined in
my Encyclopedia of Evolution and
other books. When I teach and write about evolution, I never present it as a dogmatic
belief and never require
my students to agree with me. In fact, my best student in 2012 (she got 103% on
the final grade) was our Southeastern valedictorian and a literal creationist.
I did not penalize her for her beliefs, just as I do not penalize my atheist
students. I consider this bill to be more of a political statement than an
attempt to address any real problem. Have any teachers or students brought up
cases of discrimination?
Thank you for
considering my request.
Stanley Rice
I
got the following response, apparently a form letter, from the assistant of one
of the senators:
Thank you for
your email expressing opposition to SB1765. Senator Jolley welcomes the input
from constituents of all backgrounds and opinions. Hearing your perspective
based on the combination of your professional expertise and faith is very much
appreciated.
Should this bill
receive a hearing this Session, Senator Jolley will certainly apply a sense of
balance to his deliberations prior to casting a vote. Thank you for taking the
time to write and please feel free to contact me any time I might be of
assistance.
Now,
I have nothing against a sense of balance, but this is often creationist code
for creationism.
For
those of you in Oklahoma, here is a list of committee members and contact
information:
Name, Room #, Phone, Email
John Ford, 424A, 521-5634, fordj@oksenate.gov
Gary Stanislawski, 427A, 521-5624, stanislawski@oksenate.gov
Earl Garrison, 528A, 521-5533, whitep@oksenate.gov
Jim Halligan, 425, 521-5572, halligan@oksenate.gov
David Holt, 411A, 521-5636, holt@oksenate.gov
Clark Jolley, 519, 521-5622, jolley@oksenate.gov
Susan Paddack, 533B, 521-5541, paddack@oksenate.gov
Wayne Shaw, 513A, 521-5574, shaw@oksenate.gov
Ralph Shortey, 514A, 521-5557, shortey@oksenate.gov
John Sparks, 529B, 521-5553, sparks@oksenate.gov
Ron Sharp, 533, 521-5539, sharp@oksenate.gov
John Ford, 424A, 521-5634, fordj@oksenate.gov
Gary Stanislawski, 427A, 521-5624, stanislawski@oksenate.gov
Earl Garrison, 528A, 521-5533, whitep@oksenate.gov
Jim Halligan, 425, 521-5572, halligan@oksenate.gov
David Holt, 411A, 521-5636, holt@oksenate.gov
Clark Jolley, 519, 521-5622, jolley@oksenate.gov
Susan Paddack, 533B, 521-5541, paddack@oksenate.gov
Wayne Shaw, 513A, 521-5574, shaw@oksenate.gov
Ralph Shortey, 514A, 521-5557, shortey@oksenate.gov
John Sparks, 529B, 521-5553, sparks@oksenate.gov
Ron Sharp, 533, 521-5539, sharp@oksenate.gov
Meanwhile, enjoy celebrating Darwin’s 205th
birthday.